Businesses are told to have an online presence everywhere they can, and to trust marketing dashboards that tell them how successful they are. But these dashboards all seem to give different readings and reasonings, in a market whose own experts cannot even agree on how it all fits together. The business owners I talk to seem increasingly confused about the disconnect between metrics and reality, when their interaction with customers and ROI are reflected in none of those dashboards. What does this tell us about the market of marketing?

Decades ago I ran an on-premises mailing list application, connected it to our website and dedicated landing pages, built time-based offers around it, and posted unique referrers here and there, so I could tell which path a visitor had taken to reach us. I tracked pages, interactions, link-backs, and visitor data on those early dashboards. And because the numbers could only tell me who had looked, but never why, the last step was a personal e-mail or a phone call: cold calling and active acquisition, as follow-up on everything the system had gathered.

It worked. The company saw genuine lead to prospect success.

I did not have a name for what I was doing. It was simply something I tried to understand, and to take control of. Looking back, there was nothing particularly sophisticated about it. The technology was relatively simple, the data was limited, and the interpretation was largely mine. But I knew what I wanted to find out, and I understood what the numbers could and could not tell me. The system helped me identify where to look; eventually, the actual interaction with a lead established whether there was something worth pursuing. It wasn’t “big data” yet, and it was simply in support of the “regular” sales and marketing activities. “Customer Journey” as a concept didn’t exist yet.

The Promise of Performance

Today’s small business owner is presented with a completely different digital marketing landscape. SEO, AIO, GEO, CTR, GBP, GSC: acronyms that make an agency lean forward and tell an ordinary, hardworking business owner very little. Is it organic, branded, outbound, tagged? What can we measure? Where can we finetune? A micro-management safari for the ultimate tweak, and the owner invited to tag along without anyone explaining what is being hunted.

The promise, once you strip the vocabulary away, is nearly always the same: a 360º approach, a multi-channel presence, and an integrated intelligence dashboard to manage it all. Translated: get onto a multitude of platforms, invest in digital ads, send the mailings, fuel the conversion engine, do the work.

But that work competes with the work the business already does, not the activities of a full-fledged marketing team that writes the content, creates the images, posts it everywhere and invents the campaigns. This is exactly the kind of work businesses outsource (or quietly skip), because it takes too much time, effort and money. I wrote about this before (“Why Small Businesses Can’t Just ‘Do It’ Like Nike”), but what has changed since is the structure underneath it.

There is a fundamental difference between having a marketing strategy and having to execute an entire marketing operation. Knowing who you want to reach, what makes your business relevant to them, and why they should choose you is one thing. Having to translate that into a continuous stream of content, platform-specific posts, campaigns, advertising, search optimisation and performance analysis is quite another.

The latter has become an industry in itself. And the small business owner is increasingly expected to participate in it, whether or not it’s where their time, knowledge or interest is supposed to be directed at.

Of course, there are businesses that enjoy doing this themselves, and there are company owners who have the skills or resources to make it work. But that doesn’t make it a universal truth for all businesses. Nor does it explain why a business should need to be everywhere in order to be found by the people who actually need what it is selling.

Perhaps we have started confusing the availability of marketing channels with the necessity of using them. Perhaps, as well, we are being lured into using them by being promised success through rapid A.I. adaptation.

Insights…

Let’s start with the experts. In the Search Engine Journal’s overview of the debate (“A Little Clarity on SEO, GEO and AEO”), SEO veteran Greg Boser says: “We don’t need to come up with a bunch of new acronyms to continue to do what we do”, seemingly resisting marketing-driven rebranding of the toolbox the industry offers. Search Atlas founder Manick Bhan commented that GEO is “not just SEO with a fresh coat of paint”, expressing that the optimisation target has changed considerably. And Google representative John Mueller, answering a question on Bluesky in August 2026, said that “from our POV there’s nothing really special you need to do for generative AI responses in search” (“Google Answers If Some Sites Can Ignore GEO and Just Focus on SEO”), indicating that whatever interface is used within the Google ecosystem the data feeding it remains the same.

Those seem the cautious voices. Diving deeper into the topic, you may find more outspoken positions.

Rand Fishkin, co-founder and CEO of SparkToro and, before that, of Moz, wants the acronyms gone (“Seriously, please stop with the new acronyms. It’s still SEO: Search Everywhere Optimization”). “AIO, AEO, GEO, LLMEO, and the other 15 I saw on LinkedIn today are not the way”, he wrote in May 2025. In his view the work has not changed, only the packaging: “So long as human beings attempt to acquire information prior to making purchases, (the new) SEO will be needed”.

Mike King, founder and CEO of the AI search agency iPullRank, calls that very position by its name (“Google’s Guidance on AI Search is Naive and Self-Serving”). “‘It’s just SEO’ is naive”, he writes in May 2026, “and it’s naive for the same reason it has been naive every previous time someone trotted it out”. Then he turns on the messenger: Google’s framing, he argues, is “the opinion of the company with the most to lose from a multi-platform world”.

Five people, five positions, one industry. Notice who stands where: Fishkin sells research software, King sells productised agency services around AI search and GEO. Everybody in this argument has a stake, including the reviewer. That does not make any of them wrong; it does make it hard for a grocery store or a local engineering company to understand which part is advice and which part is positioning.

The point isn’t necessarily that one of them is right and the others are wrong. Their positions reflect different perspectives, commercial interests and interpretations of a changing environment. But that is precisely the problem for the business owner on the receiving end. The terminology changes, the advice changes, and the urgency with which the next development is presented seems to increase at each step of the way.

…and Instruments

Let’s look at the clicks next. Google’s VP and Head of Search Liz Reid wrote in August 2025 that total organic click volume to websites has been “relatively stable”, and that Google sends “slightly more quality clicks” than a year earlier, meaning clicks where the user does not quickly go back (“AI in Search is driving more queries and higher quality clicks”). No numbers came with it. Pew Research Center, which tracked the browsing of 900 US adults in March 2025, found that people clicked a traditional result on 8% of visits that showed an AI summary, against 15% of visits without one, and clicked a link inside the summary itself on 1% (“Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results”).

Both can be true. That is rather the point: nobody outside Google can see the whole picture, and the part that can be seen is read through instruments that do not always agree. Reid’s statement relates to the aggregate result across the whole ecosystem, whereas Pew’s relates to the average user interaction.

There is also a difference between what a platform considers a successful interaction and what the business receiving the traffic considers a useful one. A click is a click, but not every click has the same value. A visitor who leaves after a few seconds, someone who reads three pages and disappears, and someone who makes an enquiry are three very different outcomes. Even the last one does not necessarily mean that a useful business relationship will follow, while the first may simply have wanted confirmation of his choice of future supplier.

Take one of the instruments. In September 2025 Google appears to have switched off a search parameter (&num=100) that let tools load a hundred results at once. Within days, SEO professionals reported a sharp drop in desktop impressions in Search Console and a jump in average position, across many accounts. SEO analyst Brodie Clark suggested that part of the earlier impression spikes may have been inflated by bots from SEO and AI analytics tools, and that this could explain part of the “impressions up, clicks down” pattern so many had blamed on AI summaries (“Google Modifies Search Results Parameter Affecting SEO Tools”). A theory, nothing more; Google had not commented when the reports came out. Not quite enough to build a case on, I’d say.

It seems that a substantial part of the SEO industry had been reading a signal that was partly produced by its own tools.

We already know for a long time that a net promoter score is just a number, not a promise. It seems the same may hold for more of the dashboard than we like to admit, KPI’s included. A measurement can be perfectly correct within its own definition and still tell us very little about the thing we actually want to understand. And when the interpretation of that measurement becomes a business in itself, there is a risk that we start optimising for the indicator rather than the outcome it was supposed to represent.

Mind you, this is not an argument against measurement. Quite the opposite. Measurement is useful when we know what we are trying to measure, understand the limitations of the instrument, and are honest about what the result actually tells us. My own experience with those early mailing lists and landing pages was built on exactly that principle. The problem starts when a number becomes a substitute for understanding, or when the availability of a metric is mistaken for the importance of what it measures.

Referral vs. Reach

Recently I talked with local business owners about all this, and two perspectives seem to emerge.

Some rely primarily on personal referrals. They know that their best customers tend to come through existing relationships, recommendations and reputation. They don’t necessarily want or need a wide reach, and would rather invest their energy in doing good work and maintaining the relationships that bring them the next customer. Having an online presence is merely a digital storefront; it’s something that proves they exist.

Others actively want to reach beyond their existing network. They recognise the value of referrals, but also know that relying on the people who already know them puts a limit on their potential. They want to be visible to people who have not yet encountered them, and give those people a reason to make contact. Having an online presence is much more than just a digital storefront; it’s an active customer journey touchpoint.

The distinction is not absolute, and neither approach excludes the other. Both recognise the importance of being visible and attracting attention. The difference seems to be more about when and where they want to find their customers, how much reach they need, and, more importantly, what they are prepared to invest in achieving it.

Ask either why, and the answers converge: they would rather have customers who see them as relevant from the start than spend their energy persuading people, pushing for business, and ending up with the customers who give them headaches or take up too much of their resources. Both rather connect with those customers who value what they offer.

A fit. And a click, in the human sense of the word.

Visibility and Discoverability

There is an interesting contrast here between visibility and discoverability. Visibility is about being seen. Discoverability is about being found by someone who has a reason to look for you. They overlap, but they are not the same thing. A business can have enormous visibility and very little relevance to the people who encounter it. It can generate impressions, clicks, likes and followers without necessarily attracting a single person who would make a good customer. Conversely, a relatively obscure business can be exactly what someone is looking for, provided there is a way for that person to find it.

This contrast matters because visibility is relatively easy to pursue and measure. Discoverability is harder. It requires a connection between what someone is looking for and what a business has to offer. It is not simply a matter of appearing in more places, but of appearing in the right place, at the right moment, with something relevant to say.

In an earlier piece I argued that the right customers self-select when a business is clear about what it stands for. I would put it more carefully now: they self-select, provided someone can find what they are looking for. Marketing should start with that in mind. Not with the number of channels a business occupies, but with the people it wants to attract, the relevance it can offer, and the means by which those people can find their way to it. This sounds like the most basic marketing logic, and yet, in the context of the hunt for conversion success in today’s AI-based safari, the excitement gets ahead of it all.

Slop and Spam

Merriam-Webster picked “slop” as its 2025 word of the year, defined as “digital content of low quality that is produced usually in quantity by means of artificial intelligence” (“2025 Word of the Year: Slop”). Pew examined almost half a million English-language webpages and found that around 10% of all sampled webpages showed significant signs of AI authorship and more than one-third of pages published after ChatGPT’s release in November 2022 showed such signs. One analysis of newly published online articles (Graphite, Gregory Druck) puts primarily AI-generated content at roughly half of those. Estimates, all of them, made with detection tools that have blind spots of their own.

Nowhere do I see it more clearly than on LinkedIn, and I should say that this is my own observation, not a measurement. What used to be a platform for B2B communication and career conversations looks increasingly like an algorithm-driven attention grabber: more click-bait, more AI-generated content, the “leave a comment and I’ll send you my stuff” routine, marketing material dumped in bulk, noise, slop, and spam. Relevant material seldom surfaces in the right place any more, while the level of Facebook-style interaction keeps growing. And the original, relevant, carefully made content has to find its way through it.

There is a certain irony in this. AI makes it easier than ever to produce content, but the abundance of content makes it harder to find something worth paying attention to. The cost of producing another post, article or campaign has fallen, while the cost of finding something genuinely useful seems to be rising. The same applies to the people on the receiving end. More content does not necessarily mean more information. More information does not necessarily mean more understanding. And more opportunities to engage do not necessarily result in more meaningful connections.

In a market where attention is already scarce, the temptation is to produce more, publish more frequently, and try to capture whatever attention the algorithms happen to distribute. But that can turn into a race in which everyone contributes to the very noise they are trying to overcome.

Ultimately, the problem isn’t that there is too much content; it is that too much of it is produced to be noticed, rather than to be useful.

Your Own Space

Which brings me to the thing I keep returning to: a place and a space that is genuinely yours.

For me that is my blog; it is where the definitive version lives, while LinkedIn and Substack merely broadcast it. I publish on my blog and on social media at the same time, keeping everything exactly the same. It’s a practical matter, not a principle. The principle is that what I write exists where I decide, not where an algorithm does.

There is a difference between using a platform to reach an audience and depending on that platform to own the relationship with that audience. I can use LinkedIn to distribute something I have written, benefit from its reach and interact with people who encounter it there. But I don’t want the continued existence, accessibility or discoverability of my work to depend entirely on the decisions of a platform I do not control.

A space of your own works in two directions: what goes out, and what comes in. The same thought applies to the second.

In an earlier piece (“Yet Another Data Breach? I’m Shocked. I Tell You, Shocked!”) I argued for a personal data vault: you decide what to share, when, and with whom. Now apply that same idea to the customer journey. What if the buyer held a profile of their own requirements and preferences, and shared it with prospective sellers when it suited them, instead of every seller shouting to be noticed? Less of a battle between sales and marketing, more direct and, probably, more effective.

Think about it. Today, businesses assemble profiles of their prospective customers from all kinds of sources, inferred interests, browsing behavior, purchase history and whatever else can be collected or bought. The seller tries to understand the buyer, often without the buyer knowing what is being inferred or how that information is being used. What if the balance were different? What if buyers could express what they actually need, what they value, what they are looking for and perhaps even what they would rather avoid? Not necessarily as a public profile, but as something they control and can selectively share when there is a reason to do so.

A business would then have a better starting point for understanding whether it could offer something relevant. Rather than trying to attract everybody and filtering out the unsuitable enquiries afterwards, it could engage with people who have already expressed an interest in what it does.

None of that has to wait for a standard. The concept of a vault is the horizon; the principle already works on a small scale, today. A website that says plainly who they serve, who they don’t, how they work and roughly what it costs, is a seller stating its side of the profile. An intake form with three honest questions (what are you looking for, by when, what matters most to you) invites the buyer to state theirs. Nobody is inferred, tracked or retargeted; the buyer volunteers, and the company says what they will do with it. It is a poor man’s vault, because the buyer still doesn’t hold the data. But it is permission and direct intent instead of guesswork, and it is something a small business can set up on a Monday morning. It is also what the owners I spoke to already do by instinct when they pick and choose: they just rarely write it down where a stranger can find it.

I am not suggesting that this would eliminate the need for marketing, sales or human interaction. On the contrary. Nor would it guarantee a good match; a profile can describe preferences, but it cannot fully capture chemistry, trust or the experience of working together. And a buyer-controlled system would still need to address questions of access, interpretation, interoperability and how a connection would be facilitated.

There is an obvious objection that deserves a straight answer: the platforms already do this. Facebook and LinkedIn know who people are, where they work, what they read and whom they follow. They have user profiles, yes, but look at what kind; it is inferred from behavior, which says what someone clicked, not what someone needs. Moreover, those profiles are built inside a system that business owners cannot see into. And they are scattered across different platforms and services. Matches are made by an algorithm each individual platform owns, tuned to the platform’s goals, with a client dashboard built by a provider that also sells the ads that run in their ecosystem.

That is not a comfortable arrangement, and the trend runs in the wrong direction. In June 2025, the Wall Street Journal reported that Meta aimed to be working towards fully automated ad creation and targeting by the end of 2026, with the advertiser supplying little more than a product image and a budget. The more the platform decides, the more the advertiser interprets afterwards. Anonymous agency executives, speaking to The Verge about AI-generated ads, put it bluntly: “they are basically checking their own homework”. Meta itself has faced class-action litigation alleging that its reach estimates were inflated; the claim is unproven, but it shows how little an outsider can verify.

Even the profiles themselves are less reliable than the pitch suggests. A field study of third-party audience data, across 90-plus segments from 19 data brokers, found that segments were often inaccurate, and that targeting with them improved the odds of reaching the desired person by anything between 0 and 77 percent compared with random (Neumann, Tucker and Whitfield, “How Effective Is Third-Party Consumer Profiling?”). Brokers are not Meta or LinkedIn, so I would not stretch that finding too far. But the pattern is familiar: a match is claimed, a number is reported, and someone has to decide whether to believe it.

Which is, again, the whole point. A platform profile still leaves us dependent on someone else’s algorithm, someone else’s metrics, and the hope that the match was made well enough. A buyer who states what they are looking for, in a space the business controls, shortens that chain. It does not remove the need for judgement, but it does remove a party who grades their own work.

An owned space does not solve everything. It caters to relevance, not reach: a place to be found, not a way of being found. Those who also want leads beyond their own network still need someone, or something, to point the way. That part will remain key to any such approach. Owning your content, your data or your relationship with an audience does not automatically make you discoverable. It gives you control over the destination, but someone still needs to find the route.

Perhaps that is where the opportunity lies: not in another mechanism to generate attention, but in better ways to connect people who have a genuine reason to find each other.

The Question

So, is the market of marketing on the right path?

A market where sellers are told to shout louder, measured by instruments that sometimes miscount, while the customers who matter make their choices based on things that don’t show up in a dashboard? Where convenience arrives first and quality is expected to follow? Where the one thing within reach, your own space, your own material, your own say in what you share, is treated as an afterthought?

A market where visibility is increasingly treated as the objective, while discoverability and relevance are what people actually need? Where businesses are encouraged to optimise their presence, even when the people they want to reach are not necessarily looking for another presence, but for someone who understands what they need?

And if it is not the right path: who will say so first? The agencies, the platforms, or the business owners who don’t want to be taken on another hunting safari?


https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/marketing-market-roland-biemans-f2kie


Tags

Comments are closed

Secret Link